,
Guide to Big Five Personality Traits for Hiring
Hazel Hernandez
June 23, 2026
6 min read
Guide to Big Five Personality Traits for Hiring

Finding the right person for your team is hard. You look at resumes and check skills, but you also need to know how a person thinks and acts. This is where the Big Five personality traits come into play. These five factors help you understand how a candidate will behave in your office or on a job site. By using this model, you can make smarter choices and build a stronger team for your Australian business. RefHub is here to help you understand how these traits work in real life.

Key Takeaways

  • The Big Five model uses five broad areas to describe human personality.
  • It is a scientific way to predict how someone will work with others.
  • You should use personality data to support skills tests, not replace them.
  • Each trait has different benefits depending on the job role.
  • Understanding these traits helps you find a good match for your company culture.

What are the Big Five Personality Traits?

The Big Five model is a way to group personality into five main areas. Scientists have studied these areas for many years. They found that these five parts of a person stay mostly the same throughout their adult life. Unlike some other tests, this model does not put people into "types." Instead, it places people on a scale for each trait.

You might be at the high end of one trait and the low end of another. Most people are somewhere in the middle. For a hiring manager, this scale is very useful. It tells you more than a simple "yes" or "no" answer. It shows you the degree to which a candidate might be organized, friendly, or creative.

The OCEAN Personality Model Explained

Many people use the word OCEAN to remember these five traits. Each letter stands for one of the main areas:

  • Openness
  • Conscientiousness
  • Extraversion
  • Agreeableness
  • Neuroticism

The OCEAN personality model is popular because it is easy to use. It gives you a clear map of a person's character. In Australia, businesses use this map to see if a candidate fits the "fair go" spirit of the workplace. It helps you see beyond the interview suit and understand the person underneath.

Openness to Experience in Hiring

Openness is about how much a person likes new ideas and change. People who score high here are usually curious and creative. They like to try new ways of doing things.

Why It Matters for Your Team

When you focus on openness to experience hiring, you are looking for people who can think outside the box. This is very helpful in industries like marketing in Sydney or tech startups in Brisbane. These roles need people who do not mind when things change quickly.

  • High Openness: These people are good for roles that need new ideas. They like learning and solve problems in clever ways.
  • Low Openness: These people prefer routines. They are great for roles where following a set process is the most important part of the job.

Consider a graphic designer role. You would want someone with high openness. They will bring fresh styles to your brand. On the other hand, a data entry clerk might not need high openness. They just need to follow the rules and be steady.

Conscientiousness in the Workplace

Conscientiousness is about being organized, dependable, and hard-working. It is often the best predictor of job success across all industries.

The Value of Reliability

Having high conscientiousness in the workplace means your staff will show up on time and finish their tasks. In the Australian mining industry, for example, safety is a top priority. You want workers who follow every safety rule to the letter. A conscientious worker will do this without being told twice.

  • High Conscientiousness: These workers are disciplined and goal-oriented. They plan ahead and avoid making messy mistakes.
  • Low Conscientiousness: These people might be more relaxed. While they can be flexible, they might struggle with deadlines or keeping their desk tidy.

If you are hiring a project manager for a construction site in Perth, you need high conscientiousness. That person must track every small detail to keep the project on time and on budget.

Extraversion and Team Dynamics

Extraversion is about where a person gets their energy. Extraverts get energy from being around other people. Introverts get energy from quiet time alone.

Finding the Right Social Balance

You do not always need high extraversion. It depends on the job. A sales representative in a busy Melbourne retail shop needs to be high in extraversion. They need to talk to strangers all day and stay happy.

  • High Extraversion: Good for sales, public relations, and leadership. They are often assertive and cheerful.
  • Low Extraversion: Good for roles that require deep focus, like accounting or software coding. They work well alone and think before they speak.

When looking for personality assessments for cultural fit, think about the social needs of the role. A team full of only extraverts might talk too much and not get work done. A team of only introverts might struggle to share ideas. A mix is often best.

Using an Agreeableness Personality Test

Agreeableness is about how a person treats others. It measures kindness, trust, and how much they want to help.

Team Players vs. Independent Thinkers

An agreeableness personality test can show you if a person will be a "team player." In many Australian offices, being easy to get along with is highly valued. It makes the work day better for everyone.

  • High Agreeableness: These people are helpful, friendly, and willing to compromise. They are great for customer service or nursing.
  • Low Agreeableness: These people are more competitive. They are not afraid to say "no" or challenge an idea. This can be good for high-level lawyers or hard-nosed negotiators.

If you hire someone for a call center, you want high agreeableness. They need to stay calm and kind even when a customer is upset.

Understanding Neuroticism at Work

Neuroticism is sometimes called emotional stability. It measures how much a person reacts to stress or bad news.

Managing Stress in the Office

Looking at neuroticism at work helps you see how a person handles a "bad day." In high-pressure jobs, like an air traffic controller or an emergency room nurse, you need people with low neuroticism. They need to stay calm when things go wrong.

  • High Neuroticism: These people may feel anxious or moody more often. They might worry about their work more than others.
  • Low Neuroticism: These people are usually calm and secure. They do not get rattled easily by small problems.

In a standard office job, a little bit of neuroticism is not always bad. It can mean the person cares deeply about doing a good job. However, too much can lead to burnout. You want to make certain your team members can handle the normal stress of their roles.

Big Five vs. DISC and Myers-Briggs

You might have heard of other tests like DISC or the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI). While these are popular, they are different from the Big Five.

  • Myers-Briggs (MBTI): This test puts people into 16 types. It is fun for team building, but many scientists think it is not as accurate for hiring. It assumes you are either one thing or another, with no middle ground.
  • DISC: This looks at four main behaviors: Dominance, Influence, Steadiness, and Compliance. It is great for looking at how people communicate. It focuses more on how you act in a specific environment rather than your deep personality.
  • Big Five: This is the "gold standard" for research. It uses a spectrum rather than types. It is more stable over time and better at predicting how someone will actually perform on the job.

The Big Five is often seen as more professional and scientific. It gives you a more detailed look at a person’s traits.

Combining Personality Data with Skills Tests

Personality is important, but it is only one part of the puzzle. You should never hire someone based only on their OCEAN scores. You must also check their objective skills.

For example, a person might have the perfect personality for a mechanic job. They are conscientious and calm. But if they do not know how to fix an engine, they cannot do the job. You should use personality data to complement your skills tests.

  1. First, check if they have the skills to do the work.
  2. Second, use the Big Five to see how they will do that work.
  3. Third, check if their personality fits your team.

This three-step process makes sure you get a worker who is both capable and a good fit for your culture. RefHub suggests using this balanced method to get the best results.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a person change their Big Five scores?

Most research shows that these traits are very stable in adults. While people can learn new habits, their basic personality usually stays the same. Small changes can happen over many years, but you should not expect a person to change their core traits after you hire them.

Is there a "best" personality for every job?

No. Every role is different. A good salesperson needs high extraversion, but a good researcher might need low extraversion. The "best" personality is simply the one that matches the specific tasks and the team they will work with.

Is it legal to use personality tests in Australia?

Yes, it is legal to use these tests for hiring in Australia. However, you must make sure the test is fair and does not discriminate against any group. You should always use tests that are backed by science and relate directly to the job.

How long does a Big Five test take?

Most tests take between 10 and 20 minutes. They ask a series of questions where the candidate rates how much they agree with a statement. It is a quick way to get a lot of useful information.

Conclusion

Using the Big Five personality traits gives you a clear window into a candidate's future behavior. By looking at the OCEAN model, you can see if a person is the right match for your specific needs. Whether you need a creative thinker or a steady worker, these traits help you choose with confidence.

Remember to look at these scores alongside hard skills. A balanced approach helps you build a team that works well together and stays happy. Use this guide to make your next hire in Australia your best one yet. RefHub is committed to helping you find the right people for your business success.

Ref Hub Blog CTA – Preview
AI Powered

Stop hiring by intuition.

Automate reference checks and skills assessments with Ref Hub. Get honest, structured insights on every candidate — faster and fairer. Trusted by 1,200+ Australian businesses.

Newsletter
Get the latest posts in your email.
Read about our privacy policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Related Articles
Situational Judgement Test vs Personality Test Guide
Situational Judgement Test vs Personality Test Guide
Compare situational judgement test vs personality test. Learn which tool offers better predictive validity for Australian hiring and job performance.
Enneagram personality test workplace: Hiring Pros and Cons
Enneagram personality test workplace: Hiring Pros and Cons
Learn if the Enneagram personality test workplace tool helps hiring. RefHub looks at Enneagram vs Big Five for Australian businesses.
Personality Test Team Building Diversity Guide
Personality Test Team Building Diversity Guide
Learn how to use a personality test team building diversity strategy to build better teams in Australia. Move past culture fit to find a culture add today.