8 min read

Mastering Sales Reference Checks for New Hires

You want to hire a salesperson who can bring in big deals. The interview went well, and the candidate seems like a star. However, many people in sales are very good at selling themselves. You need to know if they can actually sell your product. This is where sales reference checks become your most important tool. By talking to past managers, you can see if the candidate's claims match their history.

RefHub recommends a structured approach to this process. You should not just ask if the person was a good worker. You need to ask about specific results and habits. This guide will show you the exact questions to ask. These questions will help you find the real rainmakers and avoid hiring the wrong person.

Key Takeaways

Always verify specific quota numbers and attainment percentages.
Use behavioral questions to understand how a candidate handles rejection.
Check the size and length of the deals they managed in the past.
Use a formal system to gather and store reference data.
Compare the candidate's interview answers with the manager's feedback.

Why Performance Metrics Matter in Sales Candidate Vetting

When you start sales candidate vetting, you must focus on data. Soft skills are nice, but sales is a numbers game. A candidate might say they were the best in their office. You need to confirm this with performance metrics. Managers can tell you if a person hit their goals or if they just got lucky with a few big accounts.

You should ask about the context of their success. Did they have a great territory? Did they have a lot of help from marketing? Or did they find their own leads? These details change how you view their past success. Asking for hard data makes it harder for a candidate to hide a poor track record.

Ask for the exact dollar amount of their yearly goal.
Find out what percentage of that goal they reached each year.
Ask how they ranked compared to other people on the same team.
Determine if their numbers were growing or shrinking over time.

Hiring Account Executives: Questions About Quota and Numbers

Hiring account executives is a big investment for your company. These roles often have high pay and high expectations. You cannot afford to make a mistake. When you speak to a reference, focus on the financial side of the job. You want to know if the candidate can handle the pressure of a high quota.

Using a structured reference survey helps you stay organized. It allows you to collect the same data for every candidate you consider. This makes it easier to compare different people fairly.

Questions about Quota Attainment

What was the candidate’s annual sales quota in their last full year?
What percentage of that quota did they finish at?
How many people on the team hit their quota during that same time?
Did the candidate ever receive a performance award or "President's Club" spot?
Was the quota changed or lowered for them at any point?

Questions about Sales Cycle and Deal Size

What was the average size of the deals they closed?
How long did it take them to close a typical deal from start to finish?
What was the largest deal they ever closed at your company?
Did they work mostly with new customers or did they manage existing accounts?
How much of their pipeline did they build themselves versus getting leads from the company?

Behavioral Questions for Sales Reference Checks

Numbers tell part of the story, but behavior tells the rest. You need to know how the person works when things get tough. Sales is full of "no" and "maybe." You want to hire someone who stays focused and keeps working hard. Sales reference checks should include questions about the candidate's daily habits.

How did the candidate react when they lost a big deal?
Can you describe their process for following up with old leads?
How much coaching did they need to stay on track?
Did they work well with other departments like legal or product?
Would you say they are a "lone wolf" or a team player?

These questions help you see the person behind the desk. A salesperson who hits their numbers but makes everyone else unhappy might not be the best hire. You want a balance of high performance and good professional behavior.

Identifying Cultural Fit and Work Ethic

Every company has a different culture. Some sales teams are very aggressive. Others are more focused on long-term relationships. You need to see if the candidate fits your specific style. A person who was successful in a different environment might struggle in yours.

How would you describe their work ethic on a Friday afternoon?
Did they contribute to sales meetings or stay quiet?
How did they handle changes in the commission plan or company goals?
What is one area where they could improve their professional skills?
If you were starting a new sales team today, would this be your first hire?

Best Practices for Using a Reference Survey

Consistency is the secret to good hiring. If you ask every reference different questions, you cannot compare candidates. RefHub suggests using a standard list of questions for every role. This removes bias and helps you spot patterns.

Send the questions in writing before the call so the manager can look up the data.
Use a digital tool to track the responses.
Make sure you talk to at least two former managers for every finalist.
Look for gaps between what the candidate said and what the manager says.
Pay attention to the tone of the manager: are they excited to recommend the person or just being polite?

How to Handle Negative Feedback

Sometimes a reference will say something bad. This does not always mean you should stop the hiring process. You should look for "red flags" versus "growth areas." A red flag is something like lying or a lack of effort. A growth area might be a skill they are still learning.

Ask the manager for a specific example of the problem behavior.
Check if other references say the same thing.
Talk to the candidate about the feedback to see how they respond.
Decide if your company has the resources to help the person improve in that area.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are sales reference checks important?

They are important because they verify that a candidate can actually hit their numbers. Many sales people are great at interviewing but may not have a history of meeting their goals. These checks provide the proof you need before you spend money on a new hire.

What is the best way to verify sales numbers?

The best way is to ask a former manager for specific percentages and dollar amounts. You can also ask for the candidate's ranking on the team. If a manager cannot give specific numbers, ask if the candidate was in the top 10% or the bottom 50% of the sales force.

Should I talk to peers or just managers?

Managers are usually better for verifying performance metrics and quotas. Peers can give you good information about daily work habits and teamwork. It is best to talk to at least one of each if you have the time.

What if a company only gives dates of employment?

Some companies have strict rules. In these cases, try to find a former manager who has left that company. They may be more willing to talk. You can also ask the candidate to provide a different person who can speak to their work.

Conclusion

Hiring the right sales talent is a difficult task. You must look past the personality and look at the results. By conducting thorough sales reference checks, you protect your company from bad hires. Use the questions in this guide to dig deep into their past. Focus on performance metrics and behavioral habits.

Remember to use a structured reference survey to keep your process fair and organized. With the right data, you can hire account executives who will grow your business for years to come. RefHub is here to help you make better hiring decisions through better data. Take your time, ask the hard questions, and build a team of winners.

‍