8 min read

Choosing Between Manual and Automated Reference Checks: Factors to Consider

Choosing the right reference-checking method—manual or automated—can make a big difference in your hiring process, impacting speed, accuracy, and cost. Dive into this guide to uncover the pros, cons, and tips for each approach, helping you make the best decision for your business needs!

Key Takeaways

Manual checks offer personal touch but take more time and effort.
Automated reference checks increase speed and allow for higher hiring volume.
Your choice depends on the specific role, your budget, and how many people you hire.
Consistency in questions helps reduce bias and improves the quality of your data.
Using reference checking software can help you collect feedback outside of standard business hours.

Hiring the right person is one of the most important tasks you face as a business leader or recruiter. You need to know that the person you choose can do the job. You also need to know that they will fit into your company culture. This is where the reference checking method you use becomes very important.

You have two main choices: manual checks or automated reference checks. Both ways have good points and bad points. Making the wrong choice can slow down your hiring or lead to bad data. This guide will help you look at the facts so you can decide which path is right for your business.

The Role of Reference Checks in Hiring

Reference checks are a safety net. They help you confirm that what a candidate said in an interview is true. You use them to look at a candidate work history and see how they performed in the past. Without this step, you are taking a big risk.

When you check references, you want to find out:

If the candidate has the skills they claim to have.
How they handle stress and difficult tasks.
If they are reliable and show up on time.
Why they left their previous jobs.

The way you get this information changes how much you can trust it. It also changes how long it takes to finish the hiring process.

Understanding Manual Reference Checks

Manual reference checks are the traditional way of doing things. You or someone on your team picks up the phone. You call the person listed as a reference. You ask them questions and write down their answers.

The Process of Manual Checks

You get a list of names from the candidate.
You try to call the references during business hours.
You often leave a voicemail and wait for a call back.
Once you get them on the line, you ask your questions.
You type up your notes for the hiring manager.

Why Some People Prefer Manual Checks

Tone of Voice: You can hear if a reference sounds hesitant. This might tell you more than their actual words.
Follow-up Questions: If a reference says something interesting, you can ask them to explain more right away.
Personal Connection: You can build a quick relationship with the reference, which might make them share more honest feedback.

The Downsides of Manual Checks

Phone Tag: It can take days to reach one person. This slows down your hiring.
Inconsistency: You might forget to ask the same questions to every reference. This makes it hard to compare candidates.
Bias: The person making the call might have their own opinions that change how they write down the answers.

Understanding Automated Reference Checks

Automated reference checks use technology to handle the work. Instead of making phone calls, you use a system to send out requests. The references get a link and fill out an online form.

The Process of Automated Checks

You enter the candidate's details into the reference checking software.
The system sends an email or text to the candidate.
The candidate adds their references' contact info.
The system sends surveys to the references.
The references answer the questions on their phone or computer.
You get a report with all the data once it is finished.

Why Many Businesses Use Automation

Speed: References can answer at night or on weekends. You do not have to wait for a phone call.
Data Quality: The reports are easy to read and show facts clearly.
Consistency: Every reference gets the same questions. This makes the process fair for everyone.

The Downsides of Automated Checks

No Verbal Cues: You cannot hear a person's voice or catch a long pause.
Fixed Questions: You cannot ask a sudden follow-up question unless you call them later.

Hiring Process Efficiency: Comparing Speed and Effort

Hiring process efficiency is a major factor for any growing company. If you take too long to hire, the best candidates will go to your competitors.

Time Spent on Tasks

Manual checks are very heavy on labor. A recruiter might spend three to five hours per candidate just trying to reach references. If you are hiring ten people, that is fifty hours of work.

Automated reference checks take very little time from your team. You spend a few minutes setting up the request. The software does the rest of the chasing. This allows your recruiters to focus on more important things, like interviewing new people.

Turnaround Time

Manual checks often take a week or more to complete. Automated reference checks are usually finished in two days or less. Because references can fill out the forms on their own time, they tend to respond much faster.

Verifying Candidate Work History with Accuracy

When you look at candidate work history, you need to be sure the data is correct. Accuracy is not just about the words people say. It is about how the data is collected.

Manual Accuracy

In a phone call, a reference might feel put on the spot. They might give a quick, positive answer just to get off the phone. Also, the person taking the notes might miss a detail or misunderstand a point. This can lead to mistakes in the final report.

Automated Accuracy

With automated reference checks, the reference has time to think about their answers. They type them out, so there is no chance of you mishearing them. The system also keeps a digital record of exactly what was said. This is much better for your records and for making a final decision.

Factors to Consider: Business Size and Hiring Volume

How many people do you hire each month? Your answer will help you choose your reference checking method.

Small Businesses (1-5 Hires per Year)

If you only hire a few people, manual checks might be okay. You have the time to make a few phone calls. You might enjoy the personal touch that comes with talking to a former manager.

Large Businesses or Agencies (50+ Hires per Year)

If you hire a lot of people, manual checks are impossible to maintain. You will need a team of people just to make phone calls. In this case, automated reference checks are the only way to keep up. They allow you to scale your hiring without adding more staff.

Factors to Consider: Role Complexity and Seniority

Not every job needs the same level of checking. You should think about the type of role you are filling.

Entry-Level or High-Volume Roles

For roles like retail, warehouse work, or basic office jobs, speed is everything. You need to confirm the candidate work history quickly. Automated reference checks are perfect here. They give you the basic facts you need without any delay.

Executive or Specialized Roles

For a CEO or a high-level scientist, you might want more detail. In these cases, you could use a mix. Start with automated reference checks to get the basic data. Then, make a manual call to the most important reference to ask deeper questions. This gives you both speed and depth.

Factors to Consider: Budget and Resource Allocation

Budget is always a concern. You have to look at both the price of the software and the cost of your team's time.

The Cost of Manual Labor

Many people think manual checks are free because they do not buy software. This is not true. You are paying for your recruiter's time. If a recruiter makes $40 an hour and spends five hours on one candidate, that check cost you $200.

The Cost of Automation

You pay a fee to use reference checking software. However, the cost per candidate is usually much lower than the cost of manual labor. It also frees up your team to do work that brings more value to the company.

Factors to Consider: Data Security and Compliance

In today's world, you must be careful with personal data. Both your candidates and their references have a right to privacy.

Privacy in Manual Checks

When you take notes on a phone call, where do those notes go? If they are on a piece of paper or in a random Word doc, they might not be secure. It is also harder to prove that you followed privacy laws if you do not have a set process.

Privacy in Automated Checks

Good automated reference checks are built with security in mind. They use encryption to keep data safe. They also make it easy to follow laws like the GDPR or local privacy acts. The system asks for consent from the reference before they start, which protects your business from legal trouble.

The Problem of Bias in Reference Checking

Bias is a big problem in hiring. It happens when we make choices based on feelings rather than facts.

How Manual Checks Invite Bias

Friendliness: If a reference is very charming on the phone, you might give the candidate a better score than they deserve.
Stereotypes: A recruiter might be influenced by a reference’s accent or way of speaking.
Leading Questions: On the phone, it is easy to ask questions that encourage a certain answer (e.g., "He was a great worker, wasn't he?").

How Automation Reduces Bias

Automated reference checks use the same set of questions for everyone. There is no "small talk" that can lead to bias. The report shows the data as it is. This helps you make a choice based on the candidate's actual performance and candidate work history.

Detecting Fraud and Fake References

Unfortunately, some candidates use fake references. They might give you the number of a friend instead of a former boss.

Catching Fraud Manually

It is very hard to catch a fake reference on the phone. A friend can easily lie and say they were a manager. You would have to spend time looking up the person on LinkedIn or calling the company's main office to verify their identity.

Catching Fraud with Automation

Many automated reference checks have fraud detection built in. They can check the IP address of the person filling out the form. If the candidate and the reference are using the same computer, the system will flag it. They can also check if the email address looks real or if it was just created. This adds a layer of safety that manual calls cannot match.

How to Choose the Best Method for Your Team

To make your choice, you should weigh all these factors against your goals. Ask yourself these questions:

How many people do I need to hire this month?
Is my hiring team spending too much time on the phone?
Am I losing good candidates because my process is too slow?
Do I need a more consistent way to compare people?

If you find that your team is struggling to keep up, it is time to look at reference checking software. If you only hire once in a blue moon and want to have long chats with former bosses, manual might still work for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I use both manual and automated reference checks?

Yes. This is called a hybrid approach. You can use automation for most of the work and only call references for the final candidates or for very high-level roles.

2. Do references prefer automated surveys or phone calls?

Most references prefer automated surveys. They can complete them whenever they want. Phone calls often interrupt their work day and can feel stressful.

3. Are automated reference checks as legal as manual ones?

Yes. In fact, they are often safer. They provide a clear digital trail of consent and data handling. This makes it easier to show that you followed the law.

4. What kind of questions should I ask in an automated survey?

You should ask about specific behaviors. Ask about their strengths, areas for growth, and if the reference would hire them again. Using a mix of multiple-choice and open-ended questions works best.

5. Does automation miss the "human" element?

It misses the sound of a voice, but it often gets more honest feedback. People sometimes feel more comfortable typing the truth than saying it out loud to a stranger.

Winning the Race for Talent with Better Reference Checks

The way you check references says a lot about your company. If you use a slow, manual process, you might look behind the times. It also puts a heavy burden on your staff. By choosing automated reference checks, you show that you value time and data.

Efficiency in the hiring process is not just about doing things fast. It is about doing them right. You want to verify a candidate work history without making mistakes or letting bias get in the way. Automation gives you the tools to do this at scale.

In the end, the best reference checking method is the one that helps you hire the best people with the least amount of wasted effort. Look at your current process. If it feels broken or slow, it is time to change. Using the right technology can turn a boring chore into a powerful advantage for your business. Make the switch and start building a stronger team today.

‍