8 min read

Dig Deeper: How to Ask Behavioral Questions to Predict Success

Learn how to ask behavioral questions in interviews to predict success. Use the STAR method and competency-based interviews with RefHub.

When you sit across the table from a candidate, you are not just listening to words. You are looking for signs of how this person will act when challenges arise, deadlines loom, and teamwork is tested. One of the most effective ways to uncover this is to ask behavioral questions. These questions move past theory and into practice. They show you how someone behaved in the past, which is often the best clue for how they will behave in the future.

In Australia, where businesses range from family-owned operations to large-scale manufacturing plants, the way you interview candidates can make or break your hiring decisions. If you are an HR Manager, Talent Acquisition Specialist, Manufacturing Executive, Production Manager, Small Business Owner, or Recruiter, asking the right questions is not just a nice extra—it is a necessity.

Why Behavioral Interview Questions Matter

Behavioral interview questions are designed to reveal more than rehearsed answers. Instead of hearing what a candidate thinks they would do, you discover what they have done. It is like the difference between reading a recipe and tasting the dish.

For example, asking “Tell me about a time when you resolved a conflict with a colleague” opens the door for stories, specifics, and habits. The way the candidate answers can show whether they are a problem-solver, a collaborator, or someone who avoids responsibility.

This method brings consistency to your interviews. Instead of making hiring decisions on gut feelings, you rely on structured answers that can be compared across candidates.

The STAR Method Made Simple

When you ask behavioral questions, candidates may ramble or give half-answers. This is where the STAR method comes into play. It stands for:

Situation – The background or context.
Task – What needed to be done.
Action – The specific steps taken.
Result – The outcome of those actions.

By guiding candidates to answer using STAR, you get a clear, logical breakdown. No fog, no confusion. Just clarity. Think of it as asking someone to tell you a story with a beginning, middle, and end, instead of a loose collection of thoughts.

How to Frame Effective Behavioral Questions

When you sit down to prepare, your goal is to match questions to the competency-based interviews you are conducting. Competency means skills, attitudes, and behaviours tied directly to success in the role.

Here are some areas to cover:

Teamwork: “Tell me about a time when you had to collaborate with a difficult colleague. How did you manage it?”
Problem-solving: “Describe a situation where you faced an unexpected challenge. What actions did you take?”
Leadership: “Share an example of when you had to lead a group through a period of change.”
Adaptability: “Tell me about a time when you had to learn something new quickly. How did you handle it?”
Communication: “Describe a situation when you had to explain a technical issue to someone without technical knowledge.”

Each of these questions opens a window into how the candidate operates when the pressure is on.

Common Mistakes When Asking Behavioral Questions

Even experienced interviewers can slip up. Here are a few traps to avoid:

Asking vague questions – “Tell me about yourself” will not cut it. Be precise.
Failing to probe deeper – If a candidate gives a surface-level answer, do not let it slide. Follow up with “What happened next?” or “How did your colleague respond?”
Not aligning questions with role requirements – A brilliant story about sales is useless if the job is in logistics. Tailor your questions to the skills you need.
Skipping consistency – Every candidate should be asked the same set of behavioral questions. This makes comparing responses fair and structured.

How Behavioral Questions Predict Success

Past behavior is often the strongest predictor of future performance. If someone has repeatedly demonstrated initiative, teamwork, or resilience, there is a strong chance they will carry those qualities into your organisation.

Think of it like cricket. A player who consistently scores runs in one match is far more likely to perform well in the next. You would not bet on a batsman who only says they can play—you look at their history of runs. The same principle applies here.

The Role of RefHub in Supporting Interviews

If you are in Australia and want to strengthen your recruitment process, RefHub provides tools that help you refine interviews and reference checks. You can access structured guides, templates, and best practices that make asking behavioral questions more effective.

You can also explore resources like these: Free Hiring Guides and Templates. These materials help you prepare structured behavioral interview questions that align with your business needs.

Practical Tips for Success in Competency-Based Interviews

Prepare questions in advance – Do not rely on improvisation. Write them down.
Stay neutral – Avoid leading the candidate to the answer you want.
Take notes – Do not rely on memory. Write down responses clearly.
Score consistently – Use a rating scale to compare candidates fairly.
Give time – Silence can be uncomfortable, but candidates often reveal more if you let them think.

Bringing It All Together

When you ask behavioral questions in a structured way, you gain insights that go far beyond technical skills. You see patterns of thought, real-world behaviours, and the kind of decision-making that impacts your business every day. Whether you are hiring for a small workshop in Sydney or a manufacturing plant in Melbourne, the principles remain the same: clarity, structure, and fairness.

Do not leave hiring decisions to chance. Use behavioral interview questions, the STAR method, and competency-based interviews to predict success with confidence. And when you need reliable tools and resources, RefHub is ready to support your process.

Ready to sharpen your hiring process? Start by asking the right behavioral questions and use RefHub’s resources to guide you. Visit RefHub today and build stronger hiring decisions with confidence.