8 min read

Unpacking Behavior: Skill Assessments with Targeted Questions

Behavioral interview questions help employers move beyond surface-level answers to uncover how candidates think, act, and solve problems in real-world situations. This guide explains how to ask these questions effectively and use them as part of a structured, skill-based hiring process.

Hiring someone who looks great on paper but flounders under pressure is like buying a chocolate teapot—nice idea, terrible results. If you have ever thought, “They interviewed well, but something was missing,” you are not alone. A great resume and a smooth interview might tell you what someone has done, but not how they did it or how they are likely to act next time. This is where behavioral questions come in.

They are not magic, but they can give you a much clearer picture of a candidate’s past actions, future predictions, and soft skill insights. These questions help you look beyond buzzwords and focus on real behaviour.

Whether you are in Human Resources, manage a team, support career development, or seek a new job yourself, knowing how to ask and answer these questions can make all the difference. In this guide, we will unpack the power of targeted behavioral questions and how to use them wisely.

What Are Behavioral Questions?

At their core, behavioral questions are about stories. They ask people to recall a time when they dealt with a situation that reveals how they think, act, and react. Rather than asking, “Are you a team player?”—which will always get a “Yes”—you might ask, “Tell me about a time you had to work with someone you disagreed with. What did you do?”

This gives you a real story, not a rehearsed answer.

Behavioral questions are based on the idea that past behavior predicts future behavior. When someone tells you about something they have done before, they are giving you clues about how they will likely act again.

Why Should You Use Behavioral Questions?

Let us be honest—people are pretty good at saying what they think you want to hear. Behavioral questions cut through that. They give candidates less room for fluff and more space for fact.

Here are the key benefits:

Real-world examples: You hear about what actually happened, not just theories.
Soft skill insights: You pick up on communication, empathy, decision-making, and conflict management.
Consistency: Comparing candidates becomes easier when everyone answers similar types of questions.
Better hiring choices: You reduce the chances of hiring someone who talks the talk but cannot walk the walk.

For those in Australia’s hiring and development landscape, where work culture, team dynamics, and values vary across industries, getting these questions right is not just helpful—it is necessary.

When to Use Behavioral Questions

You can use behavioral questions at several points during your hiring or development process:

During interviews for new hires
When promoting or transferring someone internally
As part of a skills assessment process
When building training or career development programs
While coaching people through performance challenges

At RefHub, we encourage using them alongside structured assessments, especially when evaluating soft skills. You can view our tools for that here.

How to Craft a Good Behavioral Question

There is no need to overthink it. Good behavioral questions are specific, open-ended, and focused on real tasks. You want to ask about actions, not opinions.

Here is a simple formula to help:

“Tell me about a time when you [situation] and how you [action taken]. What was the [result]?”

Let us put that into action:

“Tell me about a time when you had to meet a tight deadline. How did you manage your workload?”
“Describe a moment when you received negative feedback. How did you respond?”
“Give an example of a decision you made without all the information you needed. What happened?”

You are looking for the Situation, Task, Action, and Result—commonly referred to as the STAR method. You do not need to mention the name of the method. Just guide people through telling their story clearly.

What Soft Skills Can Behavioral Questions Uncover?

You might be surprised by how much a good story can reveal. Here are some soft skills behavioral questions can help you assess:

Communication: “Tell me about a time you had to explain something complicated.”
Problem-solving: “Describe a situation where you faced an unexpected challenge.”
Teamwork: “Talk about a time you supported a teammate under pressure.”
Time management: “What is an example of a time you had multiple tasks and tight deadlines?”
Adaptability: “Have you ever had to change your approach suddenly? What happened?”
Leadership: “Describe a time you took the lead on a project or helped resolve conflict.”

These are qualities that cannot always be measured in a written test. They show up in behaviour, often when the pressure is on.

What to Watch for in Answers

Sometimes, what is not said is just as telling as what is said. Here is what you should listen for:

Clarity: Is the person giving a clear situation, action, and result?
Ownership: Do they take responsibility or blame others?
Relevance: Does the example match the question?
Reflection: Do they show learning or growth?

People might try to dodge the question with general answers. If that happens, stay calm and ask follow-ups like, “Can you walk me through what happened step by step?” or “What was your role in that?”

Tips for Interviewers

If you are the one asking the questions, keep these tips in mind:

Give time: Some people need a minute to think.
Be patient: Interrupting can break their train of thought.
Ask follow-ups: Dig deeper when something sounds interesting or unclear.
Stay neutral: Avoid leading questions or reacting too strongly to answers.

This approach gives you clearer, more honest answers and helps candidates feel respected. Nobody wants to feel like they are under a spotlight with no way out.

Tips for Job Seekers and Trainers

If you are answering behavioral questions, think like a storyteller. You do not need a dramatic tale—just something honest and structured.

Pick real examples: Even everyday moments can show big strengths.
Stay on track: Stick to one situation per question.
Practice out loud: It helps you find a natural rhythm.
Avoid buzzwords: Speak like you would in a work meeting.

If you are a trainer or career coach, help your learners prepare a few go-to stories they can use and adjust as needed. The goal is to speak with clarity and confidence, not perfection.

The Role of RefHub in Assessments

RefHub supports skill-based hiring through structured assessments and evidence-based tools. When you are building out an assessment process, behavioral questions should not stand alone. Use them with other methods like:

Reference checks
Structured interviews
Task-based assessments

RefHub’s platform here helps tie all these pieces together for a fuller picture. You do not have to guess when you have the right data.

Start Asking Better Questions

Behavioral questions are a smart, fair way to find out who someone really is at work. They help you move past vague answers and into the heart of how people behave under pressure, around others, and when things do not go to plan.

You would not hire a builder without asking about their past jobs. Why would you do any different when hiring someone to join your team?

Start building your behavioral question bank today—and see who really fits.

Looking to assess more than just skills on paper?Use RefHub to bring structure and clarity to your hiring process.
Start here with assessments that work in real Australian workplaces.